The bad news was breaking soon after we published the last issue of the Digest, so it’s a bit dated but too important not to mention here that, with the exception of a cloned dog (no mean feat), the stem cell breakthroughs to which Hwang Woo-suk attached his name and reputation were a fraud. Whether that is a body blow causing irreparable damage to the young field, or whether that will re-energize it, depends on which papers you read (unless, of course, you take all newspapers with a grain of salt.) It also depends on whether science quickly steps up to the plate to show that the science itself is not a fraud, even if a few of its practitioners are. Review the following recent advances, and decide for yourself:
|
|
Hwang Woo-suk Fraud
What effect will the Hwang Woo-suk affair have on stem cell research? According to the Washington Post:
The Associated Press also saw doom and gloom:
But the Chicago Tribune is less depressed:
University of Louisville researchers have coaxed bone marrow stem cells from adult mice to change into brain, nerve, heart, and pancreatic cells, reports Laura Unger in the Louisville Courier-Journal. The “VSEL” (Very Small Embryonic-Like) stem cells were first proposed in 2004 and were thought to be very rare and difficult to grow in a laboratory. The new breakthrough is in showing that VSELs can indeed be lab-grown and made to differentiate, and are therefore an adult “counterpart for embryonic stem cells [that] could negate the ethical concerns” over embryonic stem cell research and lead to treatments for a host of human diseases. The research team’s next step is to replicate the experiment with similar cells identified in adult humans. If that works, the discovery goes from “very important” to “incredibly important, . . . [and] transforming,” Unger writes, quoting a cancer researcher. As always, however, there remain major issues to be resolved before the research translates to treatments, which “are most likely many years off,” she says. A leading bioethicist told Unger: “Place your bets on all forms of research right now. It’s too soon to say that adult stem cells can do what embryonic cells do.” The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has approved fast-track clinical trials of Osiris Therapeutics’ Prochymal, a stem-cell drug treatment thought to reduce inflammation and regenerate damaged tissue, as a treatment for Crohn’s Disease. It is being allowed to go straight to Phase 2 efficacy trials, skipping Phase 1 safety trials. Made from stem cells taken from the bone marrow of adult volunteers, Prochymal is already in fast-track trials as a treatment for Graft Versus Host Disease (a life-threatening complication of bone-marrow transplantation) where it has already been shown to be well-tolerated. A researcher at Duke University Medical Center where the Prochymal trials will be held told Tricia Bishop of the Baltimore Sun: “There is a constant search for additional therapies for Crohn’s disease. The interesting thing about Prochymal . . . is it looks like it may modify scar tissue formation [which] may ultimately reduce the need for surgery.” Osiris is also studying whether its stem-cell treatment Chondrogen can regenerate cartilage tissue in the knee, and whether another drug called Provacel can repair tissue damaged by a heart attack. Research presented at the American Heart Association in November 2005 showed nearly twice the improvement in the heart’s pumping ability in patients infused with progenitor cells (a form of stem cell) from their own bone marrow following a heart attack, compared to patients receiving a placebo. There was also less heart enlargement in the bone marrow cell patients, which in turn appeared to lead to reduced incidence of new heart attacks, hospitalization due to heart failure, and deaths. In addition, improved blood flow in the area where the attack occurred suggested that new blood vessels may have been created to nourish the damaged area. Benefits to heart function four months after an attack appeared to be most pronounced in patients with more severe damage to the heart muscle. “The concept that we can regrow heart muscle cells would be an extraordinary development in the treatment of heart disease,” a leading cardiologist told Bill Berkrot and Ransdell Pierson of Yahoo News. “It changes the entire game.” Stem Cell Therapy for Batten’s Disease Stanford University Medical Center is launching the first ever trial of immature neural cell injection therapy in six children afflicted with Batten disease, “a degenerative malady that renders its young victims blind, speechless and paralyzed before it kills them,” reports Paul Elias of the Associated Press. The injections will be made through holes bored into the patients’ skulls. The hope is that the cells will “engraft” in the brain and begin to produce an enzyme whose absence in Batten’s patients causes the disease. The trial is causing ethical discussion over the possibility of altering the patient’s personality, and over the fact that some of the cells are derived from aborted fetuses. Blood extracted from discarded umbilical cords after childbirth is “turning out to be a medical treasure trove,” writes science reporter Ronald Kotulak, in a long and informative article in the Chicago Tribune. As one researcher told him: “Cord blood research is moving us into an era of regenerative medicine where we’re going to be approaching chronic degenerative diseases with ways to repair them by generating new tissues.” Cord blood is already known to be effective against Krabbe disease, sickle cell disease, childhood leukemia, aplastic anemia, and immunodeficiency diseases, but its benefits appear likely also to extend to heart attack, Parkinson’s disease, stroke, Alzheimer’s disease, muscular dystrophy, diabetes, spinal cord injury, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, Hurler’s syndrome, Tay-Sachs, Sandhoff, metachromatic leukodystrophy, and adrenoleukodystrophy. “Using [cord blood] cells to deliver therapies is going to be the next big therapeutic breakthrough in medicine,” said one doctor. Cord blood can cause the bone marrow in a diseased child to produce a new supply of healthy blood containing enzymes whose lack causes the disease. Cord blood stem cells also migrate to the brain and other areas of the body unable to produce the enzymes and proteins needed to build myelin, reduce inflammation, fight infection, and spur growth. Cord blood is also a rich source of regulatory T cells, which will be tested in a planned clinical trial among autoimmune disease patients at the University of Minnesota. Indeed, cord blood is “so adaptable that some researchers believe it can be administered like penicillin to treat injuries caused by common disorders,” says Kotulak. It can give someone a whole new healthy blood supply, or it can hone in on and repair damage caused by strokes, heart attacks, and other injuries. Animals treated in this way “recover to a degree not possible before.” More than half of all stem cell transplants in children are now done with cord blood, and the number is growing in adults. To stimulate its collection and use, in December President Bush signed the Stem Cell Therapeutic & Research Act of 2005 authorizing US$79 million in new federal funding for the collection and storage of cord blood units from ethnically-diverse cord blood donors and the establishment of a public cord blood bank network. Such legislation is needed because most of the precious blood is still discarded after birth. |